| What’s the difference between Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket? |
|---|
| Martha's Vineyard is a larger island, more diverse and family-friendly than Nantucket, while Nantucket is quieter and more upscale. |
| Nantucket | Martha’s Vineyard | |
| Location | 30 miles offshore | 7 miles offshore |
| Typical weather | Foggy often | Foggy til noon |
| Population | 10,000 | 23,000 |
| Size | 55 miles around | 124 miles around |
| Topography | Secluded beaches | Dramatic cliffs |
| Transportation | Free summer bus system | Cars may be necessary |
| Attractions | History and harbor views | Art and family fun |
| Cost | Luxury getaway | Budget-friendly vacation |
| Vibe | Exclusive | Eclectic |
Location
Martha’s Vineyard
7 miles offshore from Cape CodMartha's Vineyard is closer to the mainland and offers a convenient escape. Ferries whisk you across Vineyard Sound, showing you a tapestry of small towns, rolling hills and tall cliffs. The island's proximity fosters a vibrant year-round energy, with a strong focus on agriculture and artistic pursuits woven into its coastal allure.Nantucket
30 miles offshore from Cape CodNantucket is a smaller island in the Atlantic Ocean. It has a more remote feel, with vast stretches of sandy shores and cooling ocean breezes. Ferries from Cape Cod deliver you directly to the heart of Nantucket town, a hub where cobblestone streets and historic architecture whisper tales of a rich whaling past.Weather
Both Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard have a delightful New England coastal climate but with subtle variations.Nantucket
Foggy oftenDue to its position further out to sea, Nantucket experiences more frequent fog. While these can add a touch of ethereal beauty to your mornings, it's wise to pack layers as fog can sometimes linger throughout the day and keep temperatures a bit cooler. Temperatures can get as high as 77 degrees in summer and as low as 25 degrees Fahrenheit in winter.Martha’s Vineyard
Foggy til noonMartha's Vineyard, tucked under the wing of Cape Cod, tends to burn off morning fog earlier, typically by midday. This translates to more consistent sunshine hours, making it a good choice for those seeking sun-drenched days for exploring or beach lounging. Summer temperatures can get as high as 80 degrees and as low as 23 degrees in winter.Population
While both Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard offer a serene escape, they have slightly different vibes.Nantucket
10,000Nantucket has a population of around 10,000 who have a primary residence on the island, with a focus on luxury and leisure. The island attracts families seeking a relaxed escape alongside celebrities and well-heeled vacationers. During peak summer months, the population swells with tourists, transforming the island.Martha’s Vineyard
23,000Martha's Vineyard, with a year-round population of roughly 23,000, fosters a more diverse community. Families flock here for the beaches and outdoor activities, while artists and creatives contribute to the island's unique character. Backpackers and budget travelers can also find options here, especially during the shoulder seasons.Size
When it comes to exploring on wheels versus on foot, the size of these islands plays a big role. Keep in mind that Martha’s Vineyard is more than twice the size of Nantucket.Nantucket
Smaller (55 miles of coastline)Nantucket's compact size, roughly 55 miles around the entire coastline, makes it a haven for pedestrians and cyclists. You can easily navigate downtown Nantucket and explore hidden coves with a rented bike or comfortable walking shoes. The island has a walkability score of 75.Martha’s Vineyard
Bigger (124 miles of coastline)Martha's Vineyard, with a larger footprint of 124 miles of coastline, is better suited for car travel. The island hosts diverse landscapes across its six distinct towns, from steep cliffs to tiny villages. Renting a car allows you to experience the full range of what Martha's Vineyard offers. Not surprisingly, the island has a walkability score of 0.Topography
Both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard have pristine beaches ideal for sunbathing, swimming and watersports. Beyond their captivating coastlines, each has distinct topographical features to explore.Nantucket
Secluded beachesNantucket's glacial origins sculpted rolling moors, punctuated by beautiful beaches like Cisco Beach and spectacular surf spots at Great Point.
Martha’s Vineyard
Dramatic cliffsMartha's Vineyard's landscape presents a blend of contrasting geography. Aquinnah is home to awe-inspiring clay cliffs — a photographer's paradise.
Transportation
Getting around these islands is a breeze, with options catering to various preferences. Both Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard offer car rentals, a popular choice for exploring when staying at a short-term rental.Nantucket
Free seasonal bus systemNantucket's compact downtown is pedestrian-friendly and perfect for strolling and exploring. The WAVE, a public bus system, operates from April through September, connecting major areas. Biking is also a popular option for rides along the coastline. Rideshares may be limited.Martha’s Vineyard
Cars may be necessaryMartha's Vineyard's larger size makes car rentals ideal for exploring its diverse landscapes. The VTA public bus system offers a budget-friendly option, while bicycles are perfect for exploring nearby towns and hidden coves. Although rideshares are also limited on the island, you can bring your car own car by ferry.Attractions
Vacationers and prospective second home buyers won’t have a shortage of things to do at either of these getaways.Nantucket
History and harbor viewsHistory buffs can delve into the fascinating Nantucket Whaling Museum, a must-see destination that chronicles the island's rise and fall as a whaling powerhouse.
Martha’s Vineyard
Art and family funNature lovers can hike the vibrantly colored Aquinnah Cliffs for stunning ocean panoramas or explore the Long Point Wildlife Refuge, a sanctuary for diverse birdlife.
Costs
Finding the perfect balance between budget and experience is key to any vacation. Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard offer options for various spending styles, but compared to the average vacation cost, Nantucket generally leans towards the higher end.Nantucket
Luxury getawayNantucket caters to all budgets, but you should prepare for higher overall costs than Martha's Vineyard. Ferry tickets and accommodations tend to be pricier on Nantucket. The average nightly price of a Nantucket hotel room is $562. While budget-friendly options exist, Nantucket is known for its luxurious escapes. Dining options range from casual to world-class.Martha’s Vineyard
Budget-friendly vacationMartha's Vineyard is easier on the wallet. Ferry tickets and accommodations tend to be more affordable, with a wider range of options to suit your needs. The average nightly price of a hotel room is $505. Whether you're seeking a bed and breakfast or a vacation rental with a kitchen to save on dining costs, Martha's Vineyard offers more for budget-conscious travelers. While it has a fantastic culinary scene, you'll also find a wider selection of casual eateries and food trucks.Vibe
Steeped in history and maritime tradition, Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard each cultivate distinct cultural atmospheres.
Nantucket
ExclusiveNantucket exudes exclusivity, focusing on luxury and leisure. Its architecture, with its clean lines and grand proportions, transports visitors back to a bygone era. Fine dining restaurants, designer shops and a relaxed pace contribute to the island's sophisticated atmosphere.Martha’s Vineyard
EclecticMartha's Vineyard pulsates with diverse and artistic energy. The island fosters a strong sense of community, with a blend of families, artists and year-round residents. Art galleries, local shops and a vibrant music scene add to the island's bohemian charm.Housing options
Whether you’re on a romantic getaway or looking for an Airbnb alternative, these islands have multiple options.Nantucket
Inns and estatesNantucket offers a range of upscale vacation rentals, from private cottages to luxurious beachfront estates. For a quintessential island experience, charming inns provide a cozy and elegant place to stay on a romantic fall getaway.Martha’s Vineyard
Cozy cottagesMartha's Vineyard boasts a wider variety of housing options to suit different budgets. Vacation accommodation types range from cozy cottages to spacious, family-friendly homes. For a more budget-friendly option, consider hostels, bed and breakfasts, and campgrounds.Vacation tips for Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard
Here are some insider tips to make the most of your Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard adventures.Nantucket
It’s best to experience Nantucket by embracing its small size and pedestrian-friendly atmosphere. Here is how to maximize your Nantucket experience:- Accept the compactness: Nantucket's walkable downtown and readily available bike rentals make exploring a breeze. Pack comfortable shoes and ditch the car for a more intimate island experience.
- Book early, especially in high season: Nantucket's popularity translates to higher demand, especially during peak summer months. Secure your ferry tickets and accommodations well in advance to avoid disappointment.
- Consider off-season fun: A shoulder-season visit, like in spring or fall, can be the best bet for a calm Nantucket vacation. Nantucket transforms with vibrant fall foliage and returns to being a tranquil escape during the quieter spring months.
Martha’s Vineyard
Martha's Vineyard boasts an attractive blend of artistic energy and family-friendly fun. Here are some tips to make the most of your experience:- Rent a car for flexibility: Martha's Vineyard's larger size and diverse landscapes make a rental car ideal for exploring its hidden gems and reaching far-flung destinations. Consider day trips to explore neighboring islands.
- Embrace the art scene: Immerse yourself in Martha's Vineyard's vibrant art scene by exploring the many galleries and studios scattered throughout the island. Take a class, meet local artists and shop for handcrafted souvenirs.
- Look for family-friendly fun: The island offers a plethora of activities to keep families entertained. Pack a picnic basket and enjoy a relaxing afternoon at the beach, or embark on a thrilling whale-watching tour.
Co-own a Martha's Vineyard or Nantucket vacation home with Pacaso
Now that you know the major differences between Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard, you can begin planning your next New England island vacation. Martha's Vineyard is for you if you prefer a relaxed and more budget-friendly vacation. Those who enjoy living in the lap of luxury may prefer Nantucket.If the reality of the cost and responsibility of a whole second home gives you pause, Pacaso's co-ownership model may offer a win-win solution. By co-owning a luxurious Nantucket or Martha's Vineyard vacation home with Pacaso, you can access a stunning property without the burden of sole ownership. Whether you crave the luxurious exclusivity of Nantucket or the creativity of Martha's Vineyard, Pacaso can help you find the vacation home that fits your lifestyle.Nantucket vs. Martha's Vineyard FAQ
01: Is Martha's Vineyard or Nantucket more expensive?
Martha's Vineyard is generally considered more affordable than Nantucket.
02: How long are the ferry rides to Martha's Vineyard and Nantucket?
The ferry ride from Hyannis on Cape Cod to Martha’s Vineyard or Nantucket can last between one to two hours. There is also a high-speed ferry between the two islands.
03: Can you visit Nantucket and Martha's Vineyard in one day?
Yes, you can visit Nantucket or Martha's Vineyard in one day. However, each island has multiple attractions that may tempt you to stay overnight.
